Q: We're doing a minor bathroom renovation that will include a new toilet, shower door, sink and faucet. The problem is with the new sink. I want a pedestal sink, and my husband wants to stay with a vanity sink. He claims that the pedestal sink will put us over budget, but I don't agree. Can we install a pedestal sink for about the same price as a vanity sink? -- Jennifer, Utah
A: Husbands and wives often have different opinions about different bathroom fixtures. When it comes to bathroom sinks, choosing between a vanity and a pedestal sink will usually cause a little heated discussion. Even though they do the same job, they are worlds apart as far as style and function.
Pedestal sinks are beautiful with lots of style, and a great choice for small bathrooms. The disadvantages of a pedestal sink are that they can be pricey and tricky to install because the plumbing is exposed and extra wall supports may be needed. Vanity sinks are easy to install, hide a lot of mistakes and offer extra storage space. But their "boxy" appearance turns off a lot of homeowners who are looking for some wow factor.
For some reason, it always seems to get down to wives wanting the pedestal and husbands wanting vanity. So you and your husband are right on track with this disagreement, and please understand that I can't say who is right or wrong.
However, I will look at it from a plumber's point of view, and in just about every case I've seen, you can spend more in time and materials if you go with a pedestal. And if your husband is doing the work himself, it may be beyond his skill level. My advice is to get a plumber's estimate -- on the sink job only -- for a pedestal versus a vanity and sink top. If you can truly swing the extra money, your husband may go with the pedestal. But I believe there could be a sizable price difference and you may change your view. Remember, it's always best to stay in budget over keeping in style!
Q: I read your article about how it's never too late to start being handy around the house. I got a laugh out of the article, as I'm a 74-year-old woman who successfully changed an old toilet seat. It was 49 years old with rusty nuts and bolts that had to be removed. But after three hours working with simple tools, a can of WD-40 and lots of perseverance, I got it done! - Hilda, Alabama
A: Now that was an inspirational letter with a happy ending. Changing a 49-year-old toilet seat can be a handful for even a seasoned plumber. Everyone should get up off their seats and give you a standing ovation.
(Master Contractor/Plumber Ed Del Grande is known internationally as the author of the book "Ed Del Grande's House Call" and for hosting TV shows on Scripps Networks and HGTVPro.com. For information, visit eddelgrande.com or write eddelgrande(at)hgtvpro.com. Always consult local contractors and codes.)
(Distributed by Scripps Howard News Service, http://www.scrippsnews.com)
Must credit HGTVPro.com
ED THE PLUMBER
Post new comment