Owen-TV: 'Dexter' moves out of jeopardy rut

In the first season of "Dexter" (9 p.m. EDT Sunday, Showtime), it made sense to put the smiling serial killer who dispatches other murderers in jeopardy. The tension of "Will Dexter Get Caught?" created a rich atmosphere that helped make Dexter sympathetic despite his status as TV's blood-spattered anti-hero.

But when writers went to that same well in seasons two and three, the plot repetition made it seem impossible for the series to regain the grandeur of season one. That's probably still true, but through the first four episodes of the fourth season, it's clear the writers have learned to move beyond the Dexter-in-jeopardy rut.

"Will Dexter's Secret Get Out?" remains an element of the show -- Sunday night's episode ends with a doozy of a cliffhanger that gets wrapped up the following week -- but it is no longer as primary a concern. In these early episodes, Dexter (Michael C. Hall) is barely connected to the season's primary serial killer, a creepy loner played with skeevy precision by John Lithgow. Instead, the focus is on Dexter Morgan, family man.

At the end of last season, viewers learned that Rita (Julie Benz) was pregnant with Dexter's baby. Since the arrival of little Harrison, Dexter's life has turned upside down. The Morgans moved into a new neighborhood where Dexter tries mightily to fit in. His stepdaughter, Astor (Christina Robinson), has entered her terrible teens, and he has no idea how to relate to her anymore. And there's crying Harrison, who's preventing Dexter from getting a good night's rest, which inspires an amusing play on the show's opening credits with a sleep-deprived Dexter.

This all leads Dexter to grapple with questions of who he has become: Does he really want this family? ("There's this cliche that serial killers are quiet, keep to themselves. It's a cliche for a reason," Dexter says.) How can he fit family life into his hunger to kill? ("My dark passenger is like a coal miner, always tapping, always letting me know he's still alive," Dexter says of his murderous urges.)

Romantic complications arise for other characters on the show, including Dexter's sister, Deb (Jennifer Carpenter), who is torn between boyfriend Anton (David Ramsey) and her ex, now-retired FBI special agent Frank Lundy (a spectacularly understated Keith Carradine), who returns to Miami on the trail of Lithgow's Trinity Killer.

Lundy, a great character introduced in season two who sat out the third season, provides an interesting parallel to Dexter, particularly when Lundy acknowledges, "The only thing that got my heart beating was the hunt."

"Dexter" will probably never reach the dramatic, creative heights it did in season one, but with this new season the producers found a way to sustain the premise by concentrating on the show's characters and, in particular, looking at how Dexter lives with his desire to kill rather than dwelling on the myriad ways he might get caught.

(E-mail Rob Owen at rowen(at)postgazette.com.)

(Distributed by Scripps Howard News Service, www.scrippsnews.com.)

Must credit Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Embargoed for Saturday release
Sidebar to OWEN-TV